In a week normally brimming with Manchester United transfer news, an unusual silence has enveloped the scene, hinting at the possibility of a significant upheaval on the horizon. This atypical quietness is a stark departure from the club’s regular frenzy of negotiations and speculative chatter.
Several high-profile departures have already marked this period of stillness. Raphael Varane, Anthony Martial, and Brandon Williams have bid farewell to Old Trafford. The exodus is likely to continue with Sofyan Amrabat, currently on loan, expected to make a permanent exit. Additionally, promising young left-back Alvaro Carreras has been transferred to Benfica. The future looks uncertain for other key players like Casemiro, Jadon Sancho, Mason Greenwood, Omari Forson, Shola Shoretire, Jonny Evans, and Tom Heaton, as their return to the club seems increasingly improbable. This wave of departures underscores the pressing need for Manchester United to bolster their squad with fresh talent.
Despite the swirling rumors and speculations about potential signings, many of these reports lack credibility. Allegedly, United has made €60 million bids for João Neves of Benfica and Leny Yoro of Lille, but these offers were reportedly turned down. The authenticity of these bids remains doubtful due to the absence of concrete evidence. The situation is further complicated by the recent acquisition of the club by Ineos, whose operational strategies remain largely unknown. This uncertainty opens the door to a range of possible developments. Nevertheless, the most consistent rumors link United with Premier League stars Jarrad Branthwaite of Everton and Michael Olise of Crystal Palace.
The Ineos strategy appears focused on securing young, talented players with considerable potential for development. However, the key question is whether these targets are the right fit for Manchester United’s specific needs. Branthwaite, a standout player from the 2023–24 season who has earned a call-up to the England national team, represents a significant defensive reinforcement. At just 21 years old, his acquisition could stabilize United’s defense for a decade. Yet, this promising prospect comes with a hefty price tag.
Standing at 6 feet 5 inches, Branthwaite commands a substantial transfer fee. The financial gap between United’s valuation and Everton’s demands is significant, with Everton reportedly seeking between £70 and £90 million for the young defender. This puts Branthwaite in the same financial league as established defenders like Harry Maguire and Virgil van Dijk. Comparisons to Maguire extend beyond the financials; both players share similar defensive traits. While Branthwaite offers a marginal speed advantage, he does not match Maguire or Lisandro Martinez in ball-playing skills. This raises the question of whether investing in Branthwaite, leading to a net expenditure of around £50 million after potentially selling Maguire, represents a meaningful upgrade.
Maguire’s future at Old Trafford is also under the spotlight. Should he stay and compete for his position as he did last season? The depth of the squad in central defense will determine whether adding Branthwaite is necessary.
Turning to Michael Olise, his buyout clause of €60 million (approximately £52 million) makes him an appealing target given his age and talent. However, his injury record is a significant concern. The 22-year-old was limited to 19 appearances for Crystal Palace last season due to recurring leg injuries. United, already plagued by a busy treatment room last season, must consider the risk of acquiring another injury-prone player.
Furthermore, the right-wing position, where Olise primarily plays, might not be United’s top priority. The club already has a wealth of talent in that area, with players like Alexander Antony, Amad, Marcus Rashford, and Alejandro Garnacho excelling on that flank. There is also the potential return of Jadon Sancho or Mason Greenwood, with Mason Mount providing additional depth on the left side. The more pressing concern lies in the striker position, with Rasmus Hojlund being the sole senior forward. Given the high cost of top goal scorers, investing in a right-winger over a striker requires careful consideration.
It is crucial for United’s decision-makers, especially those less experienced in football, to carefully evaluate these questions when targeting new acquisitions. Ideally, the new Ineos management will adopt a more strategic approach. By the time the transfer window closes on August 17th, neither Branthwaite nor Olise may be wearing the iconic red jersey. More cost-effective and robust alternatives might emerge, better aligning with Manchester United’s immediate needs and long-term ambitions.