The honeymoon phase for Michael Carrick is officially over.
Following a dramatic 1-1 draw against a struggling West Ham side on Tuesday night, the cracks in the “Carrick Era” are being ripped open by a frustrated fanbase. While the official club channels are championing an “unbeaten start,” the mood on the streets—and on social media—is far more toxic.
Leading the charge is the outspoken Marty FC, whose latest post-match tirade has gone viral, amassing thousands of views within hours. Marty didn’t just critique the game; he dismantled the entire narrative surrounding the club’s recent form.
“A Tactical Disasterclass”
Despite Manchester United remaining 4th in the Premier League table, the nature of the performance at the London Stadium has sparked a civil war among supporters. United were second-best for 90 minutes, only rescued in the 96th minute by a sensational Benjamin Šeško volley—his fifth goal in six games.
Marty FC’s 30-minute “legendary tirade” cut straight through the PR spin:
> “I am sick of the PR! We are being told everything is fine because we are ‘unbeaten,’ but that performance was a disgrace. We started the game with no intensity and we let a finished West Ham side dictate the play.”
>
Marty’s assessment of the “tactical disasterclass” centered on Carrick’s inability to break down Nuno Espírito Santo’s low block. For much of the second half, United looked toothless, trailing to a 50th-minute Tomas Soucek strike.
The “Fake Progress” Reality Check
The statistics from the match paint a grim picture that aligns with Marty’s frustration:
* Shots on Target: United managed only 3 across the entire 90 minutes.
* Intensity: West Ham, currently sitting 18th and fighting relegation, won more duels and looked more dangerous on the counter for the majority of the game.
* The Run: While United beat Arsenal, Man City, and Spurs in the weeks prior, Marty argues those results masked deep-seated structural issues.
Champions League in Jeopardy?
The core of the outrage stems from the tightening race for the Top 4. With Chelsea breathing down their necks (only 1 point behind after their draw with Leeds) and Liverpool still a threat, every dropped point feels like a catastrophe.
“If this is the ‘new era’ under Carrick, then I’m telling you now, we aren’t making the Champions League,” Marty warned. “It’s time to stop protecting these players!”
The Premier League Standings (Top 5)
| Pos | Team | Played | GD | Points |
|—|—|—|—|—|
| 1 | Arsenal | 25 | +32 | 56 |
| 2 | Manchester City | 25 | +27 | 50 |
| 3 | Aston Villa | 25 | +9 | 47 |
| 4 | Manchester United | 26 | +10 | 45 |
| 5 | Chelsea | 26 | +17 | 44 |
Carrick’s Response: Resilience or Denial?
In his post-match press conference, Michael Carrick cut a more measured, if slightly frustrated, figure. He admitted the team lacked “sharpness and brilliance” but chose to focus on the “great spirit” shown to find a late equalizer.
However, for fans like Marty, “spirit” is no longer enough. The demand is for a clear identity—one that doesn’t rely on 96th-minute miracles against teams in the relegation zone.
What’s next for the Red Devils?
United face a quick turnaround with a home fixture against Everton. All eyes will be on Carrick’s team selection—and whether he listens to the growing cries to drop the “protected” stars who failed to show up in London.
About The Author
