Antony’s Struggles at Manchester United: A Rollercoaster of Promise and Disappointment
When Antony burst onto the scene with a goal just 35 minutes into his Manchester United debut, fans were quick to believe that Erik ten Hag’s insistence on signing him from Ajax had paid off. The €95 million deal, with an additional €5 million in add-ons, appeared to deliver a long-awaited solution to United’s problems on the flanks. The Brazilian’s electric debut against Arsenal in a 3-1 victory seemed to vindicate the hefty investment, particularly after Jadon Sancho’s struggles in his first season.
Antony’s first few matches for United promised much. Goals against Manchester City and Everton added to his impressive tally of three strikes in six appearances. For a player adapting to a new league, his early performances suggested that patience would pay off. Optimism was high as fans anticipated Antony becoming a key figure in United’s resurgence. However, as the months rolled on, the initial spark dimmed, and a series of underwhelming performances have since cast doubt on his future at the club.
—
From Dream Debut to Diminished Returns
Despite the promising start, Antony’s output took a dramatic downturn. Over two years, he has managed a meager nine goals in 81 appearances—a stark contrast to the expectations set by his debut season. This season, his solitary goal came from the penalty spot in a 7-0 Carabao Cup rout of third-tier Barnsley. For a player commanding such a significant transfer fee, his inability to contribute consistently has left fans frustrated and critics unconvinced.
His first season saw eight goals in all competitions, which many wrote off as part of his adjustment period. Yet, instead of improvement, his performances stagnated. His lack of end product, combined with predictable patterns of play, has seen him slip down the pecking order for wide positions. Antony now finds himself in a precarious position—a far cry from the marquee signing fans had envisioned.
—
Controversy Surrounding His Ajax Exit
The turbulence surrounding Antony’s transfer from Ajax to Manchester United perhaps foreshadowed the challenges he would face. In August 2022, Antony took the drastic step of refusing to play for Ajax in a bid to force through his move. He cited a lack of focus as the reason for sitting out a 1-0 victory over Sparta Rotterdam, and he was subsequently omitted from the squad for another match against FC Utrecht.
Ajax manager Alfred Schreuder criticized Antony’s actions, accusing the player of putting financial incentives above his commitment to the team. “Nowadays, everything is about money, and I think this is sad,” Schreuder remarked at the time. Though Antony ultimately got his move, the manner of his departure left questions about his character and ability to handle pressure—a concern that has only grown during his struggles at United.
—
A Tactical Mismatch?
When Erik ten Hag brought Antony to Manchester, the expectation was that his familiarity with Ajax’s system would allow for a seamless transition. However, Antony’s performances in the Premier League have revealed a one-dimensional style of play. His heavy reliance on his left foot and predictable tendency to cut inside have made him easy to defend against in a league known for its physicality and tactical sophistication.
The arrival of new manager Ruben Amorim could offer Antony a fresh start. Amorim’s dynamic and adaptive tactical approach might provide the Brazilian winger with opportunities to diversify his game. However, if Antony fails to rise to the challenge, his shortcomings could become even more pronounced under a manager looking to overhaul the squad.
—
Mental and Cultural Adjustments
Beyond tactical issues, Antony’s struggles may also stem from the mental and cultural challenges of adapting to life in England. For many South American players, the transition to the intensity and scrutiny of European football is as much a psychological hurdle as it is a physical or technical one. Antony’s controversial departure from Ajax highlighted potential difficulties in handling adversity, which may now be manifesting at United.
Representing a global club like Manchester United comes with immense pressure, and Antony’s performances have often appeared to wilt under the spotlight. With fans and pundits increasingly critical, the mental resilience required to succeed at Old Trafford has come into question.
—
Redemption or Departure?
As Antony continues to grapple with his form, his future at United hangs in the balance. The Brazilian winger faces fierce competition for a starting spot and has yet to make a meaningful impact under Amorim. However, his story isn’t without precedent. Players like Marcus Rashford and Luke Shaw have endured significant dips in form only to rejuvenate their careers with renewed focus and tactical adjustments.
For Antony, the next few months will be crucial. If he cannot adapt to Amorim’s system and regain his confidence, a move away from Old Trafford could become inevitable. European clubs or even a return to Brazil might offer the less pressurized environment he needs to rebuild his career.
—
Lessons from a High-Profile Transfer
Antony’s €100 million transfer fee has undoubtedly magnified the scrutiny on his performances. It has also highlighted broader issues within United’s recruitment strategy during recent years. Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s critical stance on the club’s history of reckless spending underscores the need for a more measured approach moving forward.
Antony’s story serves as a cautionary tale about the dangers of inflated expectations and the challenges young players face in adapting to new environments. For Manchester United, it’s a stark reminder of the importance of aligning big-money signings with tactical fit and long-term planning.
—
A Defining Moment
The path to redemption is clear but fraught with challenges. Antony must:
1. Diversify His Game: Improve his right foot, develop unpredictability in his play, and enhance his decision-making in key moments.
2. Embrace Competition: Seize any opportunities under Amorim to showcase his ability to adapt and excel.
3. Demonstrate Resilience: Overcome criticism and prove he has the mental fortitude to thrive at the highest level.
Whether Antony’s journey ends in revival or departure, it will be a critical subplot in Manchester United’s efforts to rebuild and reclaim their status
as a footballing powerhouse. For now, the ball is firmly in Antony’s court.