In the Community Shield clash between Manchester United and Manchester City, the match concluded in a 1-1 draw after the regulation 90 minutes. Let’s delve into a comprehensive analysis of how each player performed:
**Andre Onana** had a rather uneventful game, receiving a rating of 6. Despite being present on the field, he was seldom called into action and had limited opportunities to demonstrate his goalkeeping skills. The few moments he was tested did not pose significant challenges to him.
**Diogo Dalot**, also rated a 6, faced a significant challenge from Doku. He managed to hold his own against the winger until Doku was substituted out. Dalot’s performance remained steady even after he shifted to play on the left side, maintaining his defensive responsibilities effectively.
**Harry Maguire**, who also received a rating of 6, showed a commendable defensive effort. He made several crucial interceptions that were vital in thwarting City’s attacking plays. His positioning and decision-making were key in keeping the opposition at bay.
**Jonny Evans**, with a rating of 5, experienced a rough start to the match. His performance in the first half was marked by a noticeable lack of composure. Although he showed slight improvement after the break, his overall contribution was less impactful compared to his usual standards.
**Lisandro Martinez** was rated a 6. Playing out of his preferred central defense role and filling in as left-back, he was not as effective as usual. Despite benefiting from McAtee’s shot hitting the post, Martinez showed a resilient return to the lineup but struggled to make a significant impact from his less familiar position.
**Casemiro**, who earned a rating of 7, displayed noticeable improvement in his play. His passing was sharper and his overall composure was enhanced. Casemiro’s defensive presence and stability in midfield were crucial, and sustaining this level of performance throughout the season will be vital for his team.
**Kobbie Mainoo**, also rated a 6, offered a calm presence on the field. His touches and ball control were commendable, though he still has room to grow in order to reach his full potential. His performance was steady, and he showed promise for future matches.
**Mason Mount**, with a rating of 5, began the game slowly but gradually found his rhythm as the match progressed. His impact was limited initially, but he became more influential as the game went on.
**Amad Diallo** was one of the standout performers, receiving an 8. Throughout his time on the pitch, Diallo was a constant threat to City’s defense. He consistently troubled the defenders and made numerous attacking runs. Although he missed a key scoring opportunity when he chose to pass to Mount instead of shooting, his overall influence on the game was significant. His substitution came as a surprise given his impactful performance.
**Marcus Rashford**, who was rated a 6, missed several key chances, including a notable opportunity set up by Garnacho in the 75th minute. Despite these missed chances, Rashford contributed defensively with notable effort and involvement.
**Bruno Fernandes** received a rating of 7. He scored a brilliant goal, though it was disallowed for offside. As the match progressed and opened up, Fernandes became increasingly influential, showcasing his creative and attacking capabilities.
**Substitutes** also played a role in the match:
**Scott McTominay**, rated a 6, had a missed opportunity from a header by Rashford during a corner, which could have been a crucial moment for United.
**Facundo Pellistri**, who received a rating of 5, struggled defensively against Bernardo Silva, particularly during City’s equalizing goal. Playing in an unfamiliar right-back position, Pellistri was outperformed and had a challenging time contributing defensively.
**Alejandro Garnacho**, with a standout rating of 9, injected much-needed energy into the game after coming off the bench. His link-up play with Fernandes was impressive, and he delivered a perfect cross that Rashford should have converted. Garnacho thoroughly deserved his goal and was a key figure in United’s performance.
**Toby Collyer**, rated a 7, demonstrated excellent passing and movement, effectively covering ground and contributing positively to the team’s efforts.
This detailed analysis provides a clearer picture of how each player performed during the Community Shield match, highlighting their strengths and areas for improvement.