“Amorim Never Learns… Same Mistakes, Same Results!” – Gary Neville Slams Manager After Embarrassing Show From Two Manchester United Stars Against Fulham
BREAKING NEWS: The storm around Old Trafford has erupted again, and this time it’s Gary Neville unleashing a furious attack on Ruben Amorim’s decision-making after Manchester United’s disappointing 1-1 draw against Fulham. Neville believes the manager is repeating the very same mistakes that destroyed last season, and he’s singled out two senior stars who should never have started the match – Luke Shaw and Casemiro.
United fans were left fuming as the Red Devils stumbled once again, failing to secure a win against a Fulham side that looked there for the taking. Despite Amorim promising a “new era” when he replaced Erik ten Hag, the tactical flaws that haunted last season were laid bare again. And Neville was quick to remind everyone that Amorim is becoming a “manager who doesn’t learn from history.”
Neville’s Brutal Words After the Game
Speaking on Sky Sports after the final whistle, Neville didn’t hold back:
> “Amorim never learns. The same mistake he made last season that left United finishing 15th and crashing out of Europe is what he’s doing again. After what we saw against Arsenal last week, he still started Luke Shaw and Casemiro today – and both embarrassed him. It’s shocking management.”
Neville pointed to Shaw’s defensive lapses and Casemiro’s lack of energy in midfield as two of the biggest reasons why United once again failed to control a game they should have won. Fulham found joy on Shaw’s flank time and time again, while Casemiro looked outpaced, often losing duels in midfield and failing to shield the backline.
The Game That Sparked Outrage
United took the lead early through Marcus Rashford, but Fulham equalized in the second half, exposing the fragility that has plagued this side for months. Amorim’s substitutions came too late, and his reliance on senior figures like Shaw and Casemiro backfired heavily, leaving many fans asking why younger, fitter options like Malacia or Mainoo weren’t given the chance from the start.
The draw means United’s slow start to the season continues, with just one win in their last four games. Critics argue Amorim is showing the same stubbornness that saw his side collapse last season, with overreliance on aging players and questionable lineup decisions.
Neville’s Final Warning
Neville’s verdict was damning:
> “If he continues down this path, United are going nowhere. Fans don’t want to see legends of the game embarrassing themselves week in, week out because the manager refuses to change. Casemiro and Shaw shouldn’t be starting games like this anymore.”
Fan Reactions
Social media exploded with anger and disbelief after the match. One fan posted, “We’re tired of the same excuses – Amorim has turned United into a laughing stock again.” Another added, “Casemiro was world-class, but he’s finished. Shaw has been a liability for months. Why is Amorim blind to this?”
As the pressure mounts, questions are growing louder: Can Amorim truly take United forward, or is history already repeating itself? Neville’s sharp words might just be echoing what millions of fans already believe – that without ruthless decisions, the club will keep stumbling.