Manchester United’s Europa League journey took another twist with a 1-1 draw against Fenerbahce, further intensifying the scrutiny on Erik ten Hag’s tactical decisions. The match, marked by several contentious moments, not only showcased Ten Hag’s surprising lineup choices but also reunited fans with former United manager Jose Mourinho, who made headlines after being sent off in the second half. For United supporters, the game raised numerous questions, especially concerning Ten Hag’s selections and substitutions.
United initially took the lead, with Christian Eriksen’s precise strike giving them hope for a first Europa League victory this season. However, that hope was short-lived as Youssef En-Nesyri equalized, capitalizing on United’s defensive vulnerabilities to secure a crucial point for the hosts. This result leaves Manchester United winless in the competition and adds pressure on Ten Hag, whose strategic decisions were already under the microscope. Mourinho’s dismissal added to the drama when he openly clashed with officials, expressing anger over the referee’s choice not to award a penalty after Manuel Ugarte’s challenge on Bright Osayi-Samuel. Many observers viewed the challenge as worthy of a penalty, fueling Mourinho’s frustration.
Perhaps the most eyebrow-raising aspect of Ten Hag’s tactics was his choice to start full-back Noussair Mazraoui in a creative No. 10 role, an unusual adjustment made necessary by the absence of Bruno Fernandes. This decision left fans puzzled, especially as it seemed to limit United’s creativity in the final third. Ten Hag’s reluctance to start young talent Amad Diallo also drew criticism, particularly from fans and Fenerbahce’s coaching staff. According to The Athletic, Mourinho’s staff members were taken aback by Amad’s delayed entry into the match, as they reportedly anticipated his involvement much earlier. Amad instantly demonstrated his attacking potential, drawing a foul with his first touch after taking on Fenerbahce defender Mert Muldur, which only led to more questions about Ten Hag’s judgment in benching him.
Social media soon erupted with frustration from United supporters, many of whom were baffled by Ten Hag’s choice to prioritize Antony over Amad. Following the game, Ten Hag attempted to justify his decision, pointing to Antony’s strong performances in training as a reason to select him over Amad. “Amad is doing well,” he explained, “but Antony’s training performances are difficult to overlook, so I felt he could help us turn the game.” Unfortunately, this decision backfired when Antony, having been on the pitch for only a few minutes, sustained an injury that forced him to leave the stadium on crutches, highlighting the injury challenges United have faced all season.
Looking ahead, Manchester United’s next fixture against West Ham on October 27 looms large. Fans are hopeful that this will be an opportunity for Amad to earn a place in the starting lineup, especially given his promising Premier League performances this season, which include a goal and an assist across four starts. With his limited appearances showing glimpses of potential, supporters believe he deserves a more significant role, and the upcoming match against West Ham may provide Ten Hag with a chance to rethink his approach and give Amad a chance to make his mark.
The draw with Fenerbahce has intensified debate around Ten Hag’s decisions, especially with United’s ongoing Europa League struggles. While Eriksen’s early goal initially put United in a favorable position, En-Nesyri’s equalizer and the contentious red card for Mourinho dominated the narrative. Mourinho’s visible frustration after the referee denied his side a penalty added another layer of controversy to the evening, with many feeling that Ugarte’s challenge warranted a closer review.
In hindsight, Ten Hag’s tactical experimentation with Mazraoui as an advanced playmaker and Amad’s delayed introduction into the game have become focal points of fan criticism. Amad’s immediate impact, especially drawing a foul within moments of his arrival, fueled speculation about why Ten Hag opted for Antony—a decision that only seemed riskier after Antony’s injury. With Ten Hag defending his choice based on training sessions, fans are left questioning whether he is overlooking young talent like Amad, who many feel could bring fresh energy and creativity to United’s struggling squad.
As United prepares for their next match, the hope is that Ten Hag will adjust his lineup strategy to optimize his players’ potential. Amad’s progress has been a bright spot amid United’s inconsistent season, and the match against West Ham presents a crucial opportunity for Ten Hag to showcase his trust in young talent. Fans and pundits alike will be watching closely, eager to see if Amad’s performances earn him the chance he seems to be waiting for.